Skip to main content

Law Hackers for Better Legislation

Almost every country in the world has an expensive national body of elected public representatives. Whether it is called the Congress, Dail, parliament, Bundestag, or Riksdag, the process is the same: people elect the public representatives for their region, they get together in a big building somewhere and they get busy talking and legislating.


This system of public representation has several well known weaknesses, such as the potential for over representation by wealthy private interests via lobbying, funding, and corruption.  I heard arguments before that this is the price of democracy, but I will not discuss this contentious point here.


One 'point of failure' that I haven't seen discussed before is the unsuitability of these politicians to decide laws that will be exploited by professional lawyers and accountants (how many politicians do you know who have a law or financial background?). People tend to vote for the politician that secured funding for the local school, showed up at their uncle's funeral, or just for affinity. Characteristics that certainly do not qualify someone as a lawmaker.


To complicate matters, there is a noticeable trend for over-regulation The Economist has a very good article on this subject). Governments and politicians seem to be convinced that they create laws to cover every single eventuality. But this brings complexity, and complexity is guaranteed to bring loopholes open for exploitation by anyone backed by good lawyers and accountants, thus defeating the purpose.


Exploitation and vulnerabilities are two common words in the world of IT. New ones are found regularly, resulting in frequent security patches being necessary. Google recently decided to adapt a positive approach to the issue. Instead of burying its head in the sand hoping that the problem will go away, it actually created a competition offering cash prizes for anyone who found vulnerabilities in Google Chrome, their web browser. This allowed them to identify issues earlier and address them before they were exploited by criminals and hackers.


Assuming that a reversal of the law system to a simpler and more sensible approach is just not going to happen, here is my idea: why don't governments follow Google's model and create competitions for lawyers and accountants to find loopholes in our law before the loopholes are exploited by shady individuals in court? This would save a lot of time and money. It would also reduce chances that people  will continue to abuse the system. 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Irish Education is Failing Our Kids

Screenshot of the drawing made during the video RSA Animate - Changing Education Paradigms (YouTube) My heart shrinks a little bit every day when I drop my kids to school, specially the younger ones. It shrinks because I know that their experience ought to be so much better than it is. While some benefits exist in how education is delivered today, much damage is also being caused, and even worse, the knowledge exists about how to improve things, but teachers and the catholic church control of education in Ireland are incredibly powerful points of resistance to change. Take my four year old daughter as an example. She started school last September. Within three weeks, she could recognize three letters of the alphabet, but she had already been taught to pray, word by word at least two prayers. My 13 year old, who is facing some challenges in secondary school recently was offered support. He had to give up one normal class during the week to meet a support teacher. The option...

History: national baggage or an asset?

I read recently a suggestion that countries that experience severe drops in population levels due to traumatic events might never recover psychologically. Today Ireland's population remains 25% lower than what it was before the famine (from 8 to 6 million in the whole island). Ireland is a country that re-lives its history everyday. The almost genetically ingrained memories of pain from the great famine and the long process of securing independence are obvious on a daily basis. Much progress and healing has occurred in recent years, but it doesn't take much to raise the old resentment. Even apparently innocuous mistakes by UK press such as naming a famous Irish person as British (They actually tend to claim Irish actors and athletes as theirs in the good days, but remember correctly the person's origin when they are associated with any bad news) can trigger highly protective feelings. Northern Ireland has one of the most fractured societies in the world, and intoler...

Effective tax rates: Taxing times | The Economist

The Economist come to the rescue! I had endless discussions with people in Ireland about how we get far less value for money on our taxes than the Swedes. My argumentation was based on comparing notes with a Swede before the crisis started on a similar gross salary to mine and similar 'overheads', like car, children, mortgage, and so on. The finding was that although the 'take home' salary was slightly higher in Ireland, the disposable income was far lower after paying for child care, road tax, insurance and other transport costs. Since 2007 the comparison makes Sweden look even better. The table below doesn't show Ireland, but puts Sweden in a good light that might surprise some people. Effective tax rates: Taxing times | The Economist : 'via Blog this'